Now Playing
Confession as Survival: How Tituba's Testimony Built a Conspiracy
Audio is available on Spreaker — see link below.
In 1692 Salem, three accused women made three different choices — and only the one who confessed survived. This episode goes inside the machinery of accusation, spectral evidence, and the logic that turned a village into a death court.
Audio is available on Spreaker — see link below.
Before these trials, Tituba was an enslaved woman living in a minister's household. After them, she was the person who started a panic that killed nineteen people.
February twenty-ninth, sixteen ninety-two. Three women were arrested in Salem Village.
In front of the magistrates, Sarah Good denied everything. She was defiant, even combative.
The conventional story frames Tituba's confession as exotic, even lurid. A Caribbean woman, unfamiliar theology, superstitious imagination.
But look at what that confession cost the village. Tituba's testimony didn't just corroborate the girls' fits.
The court relied on what was called spectral evidence. The premise was that accusers could be visited in dreams or visions by the spirit of a witch, and that those visions constituted real evidence of guilt.
Cotton Mather and his father Increase Mather were not silent about spectral evidence. Increase published a book arguing that demons could impersonate innocent people, which meant that a spectral vision of someone wasn't proof that person had sent it.
By September, something had shifted in the community. It's hard to pinpoint the exact moment.
Governor William Phips had established the Court of Oyer and Terminer. He'd given it authority and walked away to deal with a war on the Maine frontier.
Tituba was never tried. She sat in jail for over a year, confessed, and cooperated.
Chapter summary auto-generated from the verified script. Listen to the full episode for the complete content.